Realismo platônico: diferenças entre revisões

Conteúdo apagado Conteúdo adicionado
/* Crtranslation
Linha 54:
==Críticas==
Duas críticas ao Realismo platônico se relacionam com ''inherence''<ref>{{en}}[[:en:inherence]]</ref>. Apesar das críticas, no entanto, o Realismo platônico tem veementes defensores. Sua popularidade através dos tempos é cíclica.
===Crítica à inerência<ref>{{en}}[[:en:inherence]]</ref>===
<!--
Two main criticisms with Platonic realism relate to [[inherence]] and difficulty of creating concepts without sense-perception. Despite its criticisms, though, realism has strong defenders. Its popularity through the ages is cyclic.
 
===Criticism of inherence===
 
Critics claim that the terms "instantiation" and "copy" are not further defined and that ''participation'' and ''inherence'' are similarly mysterious and unenlightening.
They question what it means to say that the form of applehood ''inheres'' a particular apple or that the apple is a ''copy'' of the form of applehood. To the critic, it seems that the forms, not being spatial, cannot have a shape, so it cannot be that the apple ''is the same shape as'' the form. Likewise, the critic claims it is unclear what it means to say that an apple ''participates'' in ''applehood''.